Where on earth is the Church going?

We need a church which is a community effective within the wider community. 500 years ago, Martin Luther nailed his ninety-five thesis to the door of his church in Germany in what is considered the start of the Reformation of the Church. I think that we are due a new reformation that will totally overturn the organisational structure of the church, radically effect our programs and many of our beliefs. In fact there are many hopeful signs that this process has already started.

Community not organisation

Jesus never intended that the church should be an organisation, or indeed 40,000 different organisations! He told his disciples to “make disciples”, not make church members. What would it mean if the church was not organisations but a collection of people who seek to follow Jesus Christ as his disciples. If we stopped being an organisation there are enormous re-percussions which we will explore below….

Do we need our charitable status?

Church organisations are regarded as charities the U.K. under the heading, “propagation of religion”. As Jesus didn’t come to set up a new religion, and we are often quick to point out that we are nor religious, it could be regarded as hypocritical to seek charitable status for what is similar to a club of like-minded people. In my previous role in church finance I was certainly glad to take advantage of the tax refunded, (Gift Aid in the U.K.) so it would not be easy to forgo the advantages of charitable status, but sooner or later this would be needed in a reformed church.

Do we need buildings?

Church buildings, whether cathedrals or church halls are an enormous burden on the church worldwide.  Turn the historic buildings into museums and the chapels into housing. Halls can be rented when needed but otherwise disciples can meet in homes, coffee shops, pubs etc.

What do we need funds for?

Without buildings to maintain and employees to pay there would be no requirements for the accumulation of funds or bank accounts. Cash might still be needed, for instance to hire a hall, but this could be handled by trusted individuals.


The church is made up of people with a wide range of gifts. There may be some who need to devote their whole time to evangelism, caring for widows and orphans or in teaching etc., but their financial needs should be covered by individuals supporting them.

Official Leadership?

We are all called to serve one another. For far too long the church has been divided between clergy and lay people, pastors and members, or between “full-time” and others. I once knew of a man with a function in the community who felt he had no status unless he gave up his community work and called himself a pastor!

Gifts vary and there are bound to be some who are recognised as having more authority, but labelling that person with an official title does not help. There may well be a need for what Paul called ‘elders’, people who are respected by all and have authority in the church, who will serve the rest of us and provide guidance.

What about church boards, trustees, committees?

If we are not an organisation but people seeking to follow Jesus in our everyday lives, there is no need for an official committee to structure us.

No alignment to political parties

It is disastrous when christians feel they need to belong to a particular party or to have support for a political party preached from the pulpit. Over the years I have heard people say:

  • “How can he be a christian and a conservative?”
  • “How can he be a christian and a socialist?”
  • “How can he be a christian and a liberal?”

The fact is that there are many political views and individuals can be encouraged to be involved in local politics but there should be no official support for any one political party. (In Britain I am aware of a wide range of individual views within the church but in the U.S.A. politics divide christians in a greater way.)

Leave charities to individuals

A non organisational structure means that it is not the church’s responsibility to run or support particular charities. However individual followers can certainly be encouraged to be involved with charities and financially support charities. But is important that we are involved with the community and acts of kindness and compassion do not necessarily need a charity.


[Jesus said] “I pray that they will all be one, just as you and I are one–as you are in me, Father, and I am in you. And may they be in us so that the world will believe you sent me.” (John 17:21 NLT)

It was the desire of Jesus that his followers should be one, united by relationship with each other and with God.

Ecumenism – or top down

“Ecumenism refers to efforts by Christians of different Church traditions to develop closer relationships and better understandings. The term is also often used to refer to efforts towards the visible and organic unity of different Christian denominations in some form.” (Wikipedia)

When we think of efforts by church denominations to produce a united church we will either shudder with frustration or be excited by the possibilities. The trouble is that organisation gets in the way. At worst it produces another level of organisation.

Real unity is based on relationships not structure – bottom up

For unity to be successful it must be based on our relationships with each other and our relationship with God. It will come as Jesus works in the lives of people to “build his church”. It will not come about by conferences of church leaders or by trying to merge different organisations.

The Local Church and Community

I live in a large village/semi-rural suburb dominated by a few local towns. Christians who are in my area get in their cars on a Sunday morning and travel to dozens of church buildings within a 10 mile radius. In the church I attend only about 6 of us from my local area meet together on a Sunday to worship and fellowship together. We know of a few other church goers who live near us, but there must be many, many, more.

I long for a church which is really involved with the community. The current situation of multiple churches is a major obstacle to the church being involved with the community. It is not going to happen by organisations merging (top down) but by ordinary christians choosing to relate to other christians where they live (bottom up).


Author: George Dowdell

I was the founder of Karuna Action (formerly Kingscare) and was the director for 24 years. I have now handed control over to younger people but continue as an advisor and trustee. My passion is to see extreme poverty eliminated and to see justice for the powerless.

7 thoughts on “Where on earth is the Church going?”

  1. Hi George,
    I have just read your column, and agree with you completely, especially the part do we need buildings. Church buildings would serve the community better if they were turned into housing for the homeless, or at least Church halls opened up at night for them.
    Keep up the good work.



  2. George, I love the community orientation. I am reminded the first Christian church gatherings were secretive affairs in people’s homes to escape the Romans’ eye. These gatherings were “breaking bread’ meals to discuss Christ’s teachings.

    I am all for church doing deeds to help the community, though. I think this “walking the talk” is how people demonstrate the good the church can do. I am blessed to have worked with several church leaders and congregations to help those in need.

    Well done, Keith


  3. yes I do believe god in the midst of all this churches are fading no matter how much churches are trying to keep going its not working ,sorry to say they are not able though have tried we as Christians are not engaging with our community but there again we can’t seem to have the people to do what is needed in the community I do believe only god can change people’s hearts,though I know of one church in my area who has a great capacity of Christians have a variety of qualified and gifted people who are making a difference in there community it’s a problem at the minute no one wants to give up there church ,sorry to say the few who are left just can’t keep it going time for change and I pray that God’s plan will be revealed soon god bless.


  4. Once again, George, you have hit the nail on the head! It is time for a major rethink as to how we understand Church. Lets stop ‘going to’ church and start being ‘The Body of Christ.’ That is not to say stop meeting but lets stop meeting with only ‘our’ group and meet with anyone who is also engaged in similar community work or activity as we are. Let our reason for meeting be to strengthen our engagement with people who are hurting rather than being so introspective. Lets do away with the control structures that most churches subtly provide. In fact, church as most of us have known it has become the greatest barrier to us truly encountering God. Until you step away from such organisations you have no idea how much they restrict your thinking and understanding of God. God asked me to step away and told me that I would find a bigger God, a bigger Gospel and a bigger Church. I have and am, while still enjoy deep fellowship with many people. One good result would be that only people truly called to full time missionary work or discipling would end up being supported by other individuals instead of what we sometimes see happening now. Stop asking for ever what is our/my mission and just start living in your community as a follower of Jesus along with others. We would soon see that we are surrounded by numerous needs and opportunities if we but stopped going to ‘church’ and started seeing people. Oops. I better stop now!

    Liked by 1 person

Comments are closed.

%d bloggers like this: